The Police Investigated the Case. That Doesn’t Mean They Did a Good Job.
By the time someone hires me on a criminal case, the police have usually already done an investigation. They’ve talked to witnesses, collected whatever evidence they thought was important, written reports and, in many cases, made an arrest. A client understandably may look at all of that and assume the investigation is finished. I don’t look at it that way. The police investigated the case, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they did a good job.
Sometimes what we receive is simply a sloppy file. Other times, the investigation seems thorough until you start looking closely at what was actually collected. I’ve had situations where law enforcement obtained surveillance video that supposedly showed my client’s vehicle, but when we looked at the timing, they had the wrong portion of the video. Yes, it was my client’s car. It just wasn’t there at the time that actually mattered. Something like that can sound small until you realize that a piece of evidence being used to support the government’s narrative doesn’t establish what everyone initially thought it did.
That’s one reason we use investigators fairly regularly. If a case involves a lot of witnesses, I don’t necessarily want to rely exclusively on what those witnesses supposedly told law enforcement. We may want our investigator to talk to them independently. That doesn’t mean I assume the witness is lying or that the police officer intentionally wrote something incorrectly. People are generally not great narrators, particularly when they’re trying to remember something stressful. I also think people sometimes answer questions based on what they believe the person asking the questions wants to hear. The way a police officer asks a question, the way our investigator asks it and even what a witness believes each person is trying to prove can affect the conversation. That’s why I want to compare those accounts with each other and, whenever possible, with objective evidence.
I’ve had a case involving an alleged assault on a police officer where that independent investigation made an enormous difference. The allegation was that my client had assaulted the officer. Our investigator went into the area and was able to obtain a recording from a nearby neighbor. The video showed something very different from the version described in the complaint. It showed the officer finding my client first and throwing the first punch. That’s the kind of evidence that changes how you look at a case, and it wasn’t evidence that was handed to us as part of the government’s version of what happened. We had to go find it.
Sometimes that means bringing in someone with a particular expertise. Forensic investigators can be extremely helpful when the evidence requires more than simply interviewing witnesses. Other times, what helps us is much less sophisticated. It’s putting people on the ground, talking to witnesses, going to the location, looking for cameras and asking questions that weren’t asked the first time. There can be a lot of value in having somebody approach the case without being committed to the original theory of what happened. Sometimes that work produces a clear piece of evidence that helps us. Other times it simply muddies the waters, and quite frankly, creating legitimate doubt about a version of events that initially looked straightforward can matter too.
But there is another side of defense investigation that I don’t think clients always appreciate: sometimes the best decision is not to go looking for something. More investigation isn’t automatically better investigation.
I’ve had cases where a client wants us to track down a particular document, video or other piece of evidence because he is convinced it will help him. Before we do that, I have to think about what happens if he’s wrong. I also have to think about whether our efforts are going to alert the government to evidence it hasn’t found yet. If we start asking people for a particular video or document, we may be creating a roadmap that ultimately leads the prosecution to the same evidence. And once we find it, we may discover that it doesn’t show what the client was absolutely certain it would show.
That’s a difficult conversation because the client’s instinct is understandable. If you believe something proves your side of the story, of course you want your lawyer to go get it. But my job isn’t simply to chase every lead my client gives me. My job is to think strategically about the case. What are we likely to find? What happens if the evidence is different from what we expect? Does the State already know this evidence exists? Are we potentially helping them locate something they haven’t found? Sometimes the right answer is absolutely to go get it. Sometimes the risk of doing that outweighs the potential benefit.
That doesn’t mean ignoring evidence because we’re afraid of what it might show. I need to understand the bad evidence just as much as the good evidence. It means there is a difference between reviewing the evidence the government already possesses and affirmatively creating a trail to something nobody has found. Criminal defense requires judgment, and occasionally that judgment means knowing when not to turn over another rock.
The same judgment applies when the police investigation appears incomplete. I don’t automatically assume that everything missing from a police file helps my client. A witness the police never interviewed might be great for us. That witness might also make the government’s case considerably stronger. A camera the police missed might contradict the allegation. It might also capture something far worse for my client than anything currently in the discovery. Before we start filling holes in somebody else’s investigation, I want to think carefully about whose case those holes are hurting.
None of this means police investigations are always bad. I’ve reviewed plenty of cases where the officers did a thorough job and the evidence is exactly what the reports suggest it is. When that’s the situation, we have to deal with it. But the fact that law enforcement investigated something doesn’t mean the defense should simply accept that investigation as complete.
The government gets to build its case. We get to investigate it too.
Sometimes that means finding the video nobody else found. Sometimes it means talking to the witness nobody interviewed. Sometimes it means bringing in a forensic investigator to look at the evidence differently. And sometimes good defense work means recognizing that the government has left a hole in its own case and thinking very carefully before we help them fill it.
My job isn’t to redo the police investigation. It’s to figure out whether they got it right, what they missed and whether looking for more actually helps the person I’m representing.
Brett H. Knight is a partner at Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C. His practice includes criminal defense in Alabama state and federal courts.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every criminal case is different, and past results do not guarantee a particular outcome.
For more information, contact an experienced Birmingham criminal defense attorney at Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C. for a free consultation.
We proudly serve clients in Birmingham and all throughout Alabama.
Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C.
2320 Arlington Ave S, Suite 100, Birmingham, AL 35205
(205) 930-9800