What Happened Before the Forensic Interview?

What Happened Before the Forensic Interview?

When I’m defending a child sexual abuse case, one of the first things I want to see is the forensic interview. But I’m just as interested in what happened before that interview took place. By the time a child sits down with a forensic interviewer, the allegation may have already been discussed with parents, grandparents, teachers, or other adults. Sometimes those conversations matter more than the interview itself.

While forensic interviewing has gotten better over the years, one of my biggest concerns is an interviewer who walks in already believing the child was abused. Like people in any profession, interviewers who see the same kind of allegation over and over can start approaching each new case with certain assumptions. I don’t believe most forensic interviewers are intentionally manipulating children. In a lot of cases, whatever influence there was happened long before the child ever arrived for the interview. The question is whether the interviewer recognizes that possibility and does enough to find out.

Richard Jaffe and I have worked extensively on taint hearings in sex cases. A taint hearing is a pretrial hearing where the defense asks the judge to decide whether a child’s memory has been so affected by suggestive questioning that the child can no longer reliably testify about what actually happened. The idea traces back to State v. Michaels, a 1994 New Jersey Supreme Court decision involving a day care teacher whose convictions were thrown out after the courts found the children’s interviews had been coercive and suggestive. Children can be influenced without anyone setting out to create a false allegation. That’s why I want to know who the child first talked to, what was said, and what might have motivated the people involved.

The research on this is striking. In one well-known study, a man named Sam Stone visited a preschool classroom, said hello, walked around, and left. He didn’t do anything. Some of the children were told ahead of time that Sam was clumsy and broke things, and afterward they were asked suggestive questions about his visit. By the end, 72 percent of the youngest children in that group said Sam had done something he never did, like ripping a book or soiling a teddy bear. In another study, children who were asked week after week whether they had ever gotten a finger caught in a mousetrap and gone to the hospital started describing it in vivid detail. It never happened. The lead researcher later said the techniques used in those experiments were mild compared to what investigators sometimes use in real cases.

We once had a case that started with diaper rash cream. A little girl’s father had put it on her when she was about three. Her grandmother later told her that nobody but her mother or grandmother should be doing that, and that anyone else who did was bad. The child then repeated essentially mirrored that same statement. What bothered me was that the forensic interviewer never recognized the significance of the grandmother’s conversation. You can’t properly evaluate what that child said without knowing where the language came from.

In that case, our firm filed a taint motion. We argue the suggestion and manipulation started with a family member and continued through conversations with other relatives and interviews with the Department of Human Resources. At the time, there was almost no Alabama law on the subject, so we relied on decisions from other states, the research, and the facts of our case. The judge gave us an all-day hearing, and we were able to cross-examine each of the State’s witnesses about how the child’s account developed. The State ultimately dismissed the charges, in large part because of what came out at that hearing.

I’ve also seen allegations change substantially as a case goes along. In one recent case, the initial allegation involved touching. By the time the child testified, she was describing rape and anal sodomy. I’ve seen allegations grow between the first disclosure and the forensic interview, too. When new details show up, I want to know when they first appeared, who was in the room, and what questions came right before them. New information isn’t automatically false. It just shouldn’t be accepted without looking at how it developed.

In one case we tried, the forensic interviewer actually helped us. The child testified about penetration and said she had told the interviewer about it. The interviewer stood by her original account and testified that the child never mentioned penetration to her. That was important for the jury to hear, and we only had it because the interview was recorded and this interviewer was willing to stand behind what actually happened in the interview.

That’s the value of recorded interviews. We can see exactly what was asked and answered instead of relying on someone’s summary. Before recording was routine, interviewers often relied on their notes, and one study found that more than half of what the interviewers said, and a quarter of the details the children gave, never made it into those notes. But there’s another side to it. Under Alabama’s Child Physical and Sexual Abuse Victim Protection Act, certain recorded statements can be admitted at trial if the statutory requirements are met. So the same recording that lets the defense pick apart the interview may also end up in front of the jury. That makes the reliability of the interview, and what happened before it, even more important.

The hard part is explaining all of this to a jury. In my experience, jurors have a difficult time believing a child could make an inaccurate allegation of sexual abuse. We all know children sometimes say things that aren’t true. But when a child takes the stand and describes something this serious, people understandably want to believe that child. What’s harder to appreciate is that a child can sincerely believe an account that has been shaped by conversations and suggestions over time. That isn’t the same as lying, and quite frankly, it can be harder to expose.

I don’t go into these cases assuming every child is lying or every interviewer did something wrong. But an accusation this serious is no reason to ignore how it started. Sometimes the most important part of a forensic interview is what happened before anyone turned on the camera.


Attorney Brett Knight

Brett H. Knight is a partner at Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C. His practice includes criminal defense in Alabama state and federal courts.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every criminal case is different, and past results do not guarantee a particular outcome.

For more information, contact an experienced Birmingham criminal defense attorney at Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C. for a free consultation.

We proudly serve clients in Birmingham and all throughout Alabama.

Jaffe, Hanle, Whisonant & Knight, P.C.
2320 Arlington Ave S, Suite 100, Birmingham, AL 35205
(205) 930-9800